The quick test: does it crumble?
UC IPM's bat pest note gives the simplest field test: bat droppings (guano) crush easily and reveal shiny bits of undigested insects, while mouse droppings lack the shiny bits. That's because Southern California's house-roosting bats, such as the Mexican free-tailed bat and the big brown bat, eat only insects, so their droppings are mostly dry fragments of wings and exoskeletons. Rodent droppings are made of digested plant material, seeds and whatever else the animal has been eating, so they are firmer and harden as they dry. Don't do this test with bare fingers or by sniffing up close. Put on disposable gloves and a mask, and press a single dropping with a stick, a pencil or the tip of a screwdriver on a paper towel. If it collapses into a dry, glittery powder, it's almost certainly bat guano. If it stays in one piece or smears, it's more likely a rodent.
Size and shape
Size alone won't settle it, because bat guano and mouse droppings overlap. University of Arizona Cooperative Extension says house mouse droppings are 1/8 to 1/4 inch long and pointed at both ends, and rat droppings are larger, about 1/2 to 1 inch long. The Orange County Mosquito and Vector Control District describes roof rat droppings as dark in color, spindle-shaped and about 1/2 inch long, and Arizona Extension's roof rat fact sheet says they are black, banana-shaped and 1/4 to 1/2 inch long. Bat droppings from the small bats that roost in Southern California homes are usually in the mouse size range. They are dark brown to black, and the crumble test above is a better guide than a ruler. Note also what you're not seeing: UC IPM says bat droppings are never white or chalky the way bird droppings are, so white-tipped or chalky splats on a ledge point to birds, not bats.
Where the droppings are tells you as much as what they look like
Pattern is often the giveaway. Bats leave and return through the same small gaps and roost in the same spots, so their droppings pile up. UC IPM says droppings and urine accumulate beneath roosts, and that droppings beneath openings help locate roosts and entry points. Look for a cone or pile in the attic under the ridge or a gable peak, a scatter on the ground, a windowsill or a patio below one spot on the eave, droppings stuck to the stucco or siding under a gap, or a dark streak of body-oil staining around the opening itself. Rats are different. OC Vector Control says rat droppings are randomly scattered and are normally found close to a runway, a feeding location or a shelter. In practice that means droppings along the tops of walls, beams and attic insulation, near stored food, pet food or bird seed in the garage, and in water heater closets and around pool heater covers. UC IPM and OC Vector Control list gnawing, partly eaten fruit and nuts from backyard trees and smudge or grease marks along beams and rafters as rat signs too, and bats don't make any of them.
Other clues: smell, sound and timing
UC IPM says being alert to off odors can help you find a bat roost, and that droppings and urine accumulating beneath a roost create odors and attract insects. Bats are quiet during the day, but you may hear scratching or squeaking in a wall or ceiling around sunset as they wake up and leave. You can confirm bats by watching the roofline from outside for 30 minutes starting just before sunset: bats drop out of a gap and fly off. Rats are most active at night. Homeowners hear them running across ceilings and in walls, and OC Vector Control says residents often see them traveling along utility lines and the tops of fences. In Southern California, bat activity at a roost drops in winter but often doesn't stop entirely, so fresh droppings in December don't rule out bats. If a pile looks old and dusty, lay a sheet of paper flat next to it, without disturbing the droppings, and check it again after a few days for fresh ones.
Health risks: hantavirus, histoplasmosis and rabies
The two kinds of droppings carry different risks, and neither should be swept up dry. For rodents, the CDC says diseases are mainly spread to people when they breathe in contaminated air, and warns that vacuuming or sweeping urine, droppings or nests can put virus-laden droplets in the air. The California Department of Public Health says the hantavirus that causes hantavirus pulmonary syndrome in California, Sin Nombre virus, is carried by deer mice, and that the disease is rare but often fatal. For bats, the main concern with guano is histoplasmosis. The CDC says it is a lung infection caused by breathing in spores of the fungus Histoplasma, which lives in soil and spreads in bird and bat droppings that mix into it, and that in the United States the fungus mainly lives in central and eastern states. UC IPM says bat and bird droppings enhance the fungus's development and that anyone cleaning up either should wear a respirator that filters particles as small as 2 micrometers. Rabies is a separate question. UC IPM says there is no evidence of rabies transmission through contact with bat urine or feces; the rabies risk comes from bites, scratches and handling bats. So droppings by themselves aren't a rabies exposure, but a live bat inside the living space is something to take seriously.
How to clean up rodent droppings safely
If the droppings are from rodents, the CDC's cleanup steps are: open doors and windows and leave the area for 30 minutes before you start; put on rubber or plastic gloves; spray the urine and droppings with a disinfectant or a fresh bleach solution (1.5 cups of household bleach per gallon of water, or 1 part bleach to 9 parts water) until very wet and let it soak for 5 minutes; wipe up with paper towels and throw them in a covered garbage can; then mop or sponge the area with disinfectant and wash your gloved hands before taking the gloves off. Don't vacuum or sweep first. For a heavy infestation, the CDC recommends coveralls, goggles and a HEPA-filter respirator, and contaminated insulation should be bagged and removed. Cleaning up doesn't solve the problem, though. Roof rats will keep coming back until the entry points are sealed and the food and shelter around the house are dealt with. Orange County residents can report rats to OC Vector Control through its Report an Issue page; elsewhere, ask your city or county vector control agency what rodent help it offers.
Bat guano: why cleanup comes after exclusion
With bats, the order matters. Clean up guano while the colony is still living there and you'll be cleaning again in a few weeks. The bats have to be out first, and bats are protected in California. UC IPM says eviction and exclusion are the only safe and permanent remedies once droppings accumulate. L.A. County Veterinary Public Health asks residents not to exclude bats in the summer months (May–August), because the young inside can't leave and will die, and says late fall and winter are the best time to bat-proof a home. That makes the season when you find droppings while getting the holiday decorations down a good time to act. After the colony has been excluded with one-way devices and the gaps are sealed, the guano and soiled insulation can be removed with respirators and containment and the attic sanitized. A small scatter of dry droppings under an eave outside can be dampened and wiped up wearing gloves and a mask. A pile in the attic or soaked insulation calls for professional guano cleanup.
Still not sure? What we look for
When you aren't sure, a short inspection settles it. On an attic inspection we check the droppings (crumble test, size and pattern), look for urine staining and grease marks at the eaves, vents, tile ends and fascia joints where bats enter, and look for rodent signs such as gnawing, nesting material and runways. If it's bats, we confirm the species where we can, map every entry point, and plan exclusion outside the pup season. If it's rodents, we tell you so and point you to a pest control company or your vector control district rather than selling you a bat job. Sometimes it's both, and older Southern California homes with loose fascia and open tile ends can have bats and rats in the same attic.
Ready for help in Los Angeles, San Diego, or elsewhere in Southern California? Start with bat removal or an attic inspection.
Sources
- UC IPM Pest Notes: Bats (guano identification, roost signs, histoplasmosis)
- UC IPM Pest Notes: Rats
- Orange County Mosquito and Vector Control District: Checking for roof rat activity
- Orange County Mosquito and Vector Control District: Domestic Rats (fact sheet)
- Orange County Mosquito and Vector Control District: Report an Issue
- University of Arizona Cooperative Extension: Commensal Rodents
- University of Arizona Cooperative Extension: Roof Rats, Identification, Ecology and Signs (AZ1775)
- CDC: How to Clean Up After Rodents
- CDC: About Histoplasmosis
- CDPH: Hantavirus Occupational Health Toolkit (Sin Nombre virus and deer mice)
- L.A. County Veterinary Public Health: Bats in Los Angeles County
